Tree Fund header image

Failure potential of limbs receiving reduction or heading cuts and of resulting sprouts, in directional, structural or restoration pruning

2011 | Dr. Edward Gilman, University of Florida 

Structural pruning, directional pruning, restoration pruning, and crown reduction are recommended methods for arborists to use when performing tree care operations. All of these methods use reduction cuts to meet their objectives. There is no data, however, on the long-term impacts of reduction cuts on branch breaking strength. Two studies will be performed to investigate this. The first seeks to determine the influence of directional pruning, crown reduction, structural pruning, and restoration pruning on failure potential of retained limbs under load, and decay of large limbs. Load will simulate that from ice, snow, or wind downbursts. Oaks pruned in 2004 with reduction cuts ranging in size from 4 to 9 inches in diameter will be pulled with a winch to failure. Influence of reduction cuts on structural strength will be measured. Primary objectives are 1) determine if limbs fail at the site of the 7 to 8 year-old pruning cuts or at other places, and 2) compare failure patterns on pruned limbs with failure patterns on limbs not pruned. Discoloration, cracks, barrier zones, decay, wound wood formation, limb taper, mechanical stress at failure, and other attributes will be quantified and related to size of cut and point of failure. The second study evaluates strength of attachment and failure patterns of 2- to 5-inch diameter upright-oriented sprouts growing on trees pruned to simulate storm damage (i.e. essentially they were topped in 2006). Some sprouts are growing from vertical stems originating just behind the 2- to 4-inch diameter heading cuts, whereas others emerge from horizontal lateral limbs. Sprouts will be pulled parallel to gravity using a single attachment point to the limb to simulate load from ice, snow, or wind.


For more information on this project, contact the researcher via TREE Fund at


Save the Dates

You don't want to miss our TWO webinars in May: Invasive Insects of Shade Trees (May 2) and a Utility Arborist Research Fund Update (May 23). Registration for both opens on April 2 HERE.

close window